Censorship of Al Jazeera's 'The Lobby USA' Documentary

Censure du documentaire Al Jazeera 'The Lobby USA'

Documented
0.82
Credibility score
Geopolitical CensureLobbyingMediasInfluence israelienne Confirmed First appearance : 2017-2018

Summary

Al Jazeera infiltrated pro-Israel organizations in Washington with an undercover journalist in 2016. A four-part documentary was produced but NEVER broadcast. In February 2018, Qatari leaders assured American Jewish organization leaders that the documentary would not be broadcast. It was ultimately disclosed in November 2018 by The Electronic Intifada, Orient XXI, and Al Akhbar.

Detailed description

CONTEXT: Parallel to the documentary 'The Lobby' on the United Kingdom (released in January 2017), Al Jazeera had infiltrated a journalist undercover into pro-Israel organizations in Washington in 2016.

PRODUCTION:

  • Undercover journalist installed in pro-Israel organizations in Washington
  • Clayton Swisher (Al Jazeera Investigations director) confirms the operation
  • Four-part documentary produced

CENSURE:

  • October 2017: Al Jazeera announces the documentary
  • February 2018: it is reported that Qatari leaders reassured leaders of American Jewish organizations that the documentary would NOT be broadcast
  • The documentary was NEVER broadcast by Al Jazeera

LEAK:

  • November 2018: The Electronic Intifada publishes the four episodes simultaneously with Orient XXI (France) and Al Akhbar (Lebanon)

INTERPRETATION:

  • For critics of the lobby: the censure proves the power of the pro-Israel lobby -- even a state media outlet (Al Jazeera/Qatar) yields to pressure
  • Nuance: Qatar had its own diplomatic interests in accommodating the USA and American Jewish organizations (Saudi Arabian blockade, Al Udeid American military base)

UK VERSION (FOR COMPARISON):

  • Normally broadcast in January 2017
  • Features Shai Masot (Israeli diplomat) discussing 'bringing down' British MPs
  • Masot recalled to Israel, diplomatic apologies

Key claims

1

Al Jazeera a infiltre des organisations pro-Israel a Washington (FAIT DOCUMENTE)

2

Le documentaire a ete produit mais JAMAIS diffuse (FAIT DOCUMENTE)

3

Les dirigeants qataris ont cede a la pression (FAIT DOCUMENTE - rapporte par plusieurs sources)

4

La censure prouve la puissance du lobby pro-Israel (PARTIELLEMENT CORROBORE - mais d'autres facteurs ont joue)

5

Le documentaire revele des pratiques d'espionnage et de manipulation par le lobby (DOCUMENTE dans le contenu divulgue)

Evidence FOR (3)

Le documentaire existe et a ete divulgue -- son contenu est verifiable

Source : Electronic Intifada, novembre 2018

Strength : fort

Al Jazeera a confirme la production et la non-diffusion

Source : Declarations d'Al Jazeera

Strength : fort

La version UK a ete diffusee et a provoque un scandale (Shai Masot)

Source : Al Jazeera, janvier 2017

Strength : fort

Evidence AGAINST (1)

Le Qatar avait des raisons diplomatiques propres de ne pas diffuser (blocus saoudien, base Al Udeid)

Source : Analyse geopolitique

Strength : moyen

Timeline

2016

Journaliste sous couverture infiltre les organisations pro-Israel a Washington

Janvier 2017

Version UK diffusee normalement. Scandale Masot

Octobre 2017

Al Jazeera annonce le documentaire US

Fevrier 2018

Decision de ne pas diffuser. Pression des organisations juives americaines

Novembre 2018

Fuite du documentaire par Electronic Intifada, Orient XXI, Al Akhbar

Factchecks (2)

FC-0534 CONFIRMED 0

Fait documentaire incontestable. Score index grotesquement sous-evalue vs fichier. Corrige au fichier.

Summary

Fait documentaire incontestable. Score index grotesquement sous-evalue vs fichier. Corrige au fichier.

FC-0129 VRAI 50% Le Factchecker 2026-02-28

Claim checked

Al Jazeera a produit un documentaire infiltré sur le lobby pro-Israël jamais diffusé