Pizzagate

Debunked
0.01
Credibility score
Pedocriminality Reseaux pedocriminels alleguesDesinformation politiqueTheories du complot electorales Debunked First appearance : Octobre-novembre 2016

Summary

Pizzagate is a debunked conspiracy theory alleging that emails from John Podesta (Hillary Clinton’s campaign manager), published by WikiLeaks in October 2016, contained coded messages referencing a pedocriminal network operating from the Comet Ping Pong restaurant in Washington D.C. The theory has been exhaustively refuted but led Edgar Maddison Welch to enter the restaurant armed on December 4, 2016. Pizzagate is considered a direct precursor to QAnon.

Detailed description

In October 2016, WikiLeaks published thousands of emails hacked from the account of John Podesta, Hillary Clinton’s campaign manager. Users of 4chan (/pol/) and Reddit (r/The_Donald, r/pizzagate) identified within these emails frequent references to foods (pizza, hot dogs, cheese, pasta, sauce) which they interpreted as a ‘pedophile code,’ each food item designating a type of victim or sexual activity. This interpretive framework was based on no credible source in criminology.

The Comet Ping Pong restaurant, a pizzeria in Washington D.C. whose owner James Alefantis is a friend of Podesta and former partner of David Brock (founder of Media Matters), became the primary target. Theorists alleged that the restaurant's basement (which does not have a basement) housed a child trafficking network. Alefantis’s Instagram accounts were scrutinized, and photos of children (restaurant patrons of the family-friendly establishment with a game room) were reinterpreted as ‘evidence.’

The theory spread virally on Twitter, Facebook, Reddit, and YouTube during the 2016 presidential campaign. The subreddit r/pizzagate was banned by Reddit on November 22, 2016. Conservative media figures such as Michael Flynn Jr. (son of General Michael Flynn), Jack Posobiec, and certain contributors to Infowars amplified the theory.

On December 4, 2016, Edgar Maddison Welch, 28 years old, originally from North Carolina, entered the Comet Ping Pong restaurant armed with an AR-15 assault rifle to 'investigate' himself. He fired several shots (without causing any injuries), searched the premises without finding anything, and surrendered to the police. He was sentenced in June 2017 to 4 years in prison.

Investigations by the FBI, the Washington Metropolitan Police Department, and numerous fact-checking organizations (Snopes, PolitiFact, FactCheck.org, New York Times, Washington Post) unanimously concluded that there is no evidence supporting the theory. The alleged ‘food code’ does not appear in any criminology textbook or law enforcement report. The restaurant has no basement.

Pizzagate is considered a pivotal moment in the history of online disinformation and a direct precursor to QAnon, which adopts and expands the narrative of an elite pedocriminal network.

Key claims

1

Les emails de Podesta contiennent des messages codes faisant reference a la pedocriminalite

2

Des termes alimentaires (pizza, hot-dog, fromage, pates) sont des codes pour des activites pedophiles

3

Le restaurant Comet Ping Pong a Washington D.C. est un lieu de trafic d'enfants

4

James Alefantis (proprietaire de Comet Ping Pong) est implique dans un reseau pedocriminel

5

Hillary Clinton et John Podesta sont au coeur de ce reseau

6

Un sous-sol secret sous le restaurant abrite les victimes

7

Les images du compte Instagram d'Alefantis contiennent des 'preuves' codees

8

David Brock (Media Matters) fait partie du reseau

Evidence FOR (3)

Les emails Podesta publies par WikiLeaks sont authentiques

Source : WikiLeaks, confirmation par Podesta et la campagne Clinton

Strength : fort

Certains emails contiennent effectivement des references alimentaires dans des contextes parfois maladroits ou ambigus

Source : Emails WikiLeaks

Strength : faible

James Alefantis est effectivement un ami de Podesta et figure de la vie sociale washingtonienne

Source : Faits publics

Strength : faible

Evidence AGAINST (6)

Le 'code alimentaire' allegue n'apparait dans aucune source credible d'application de la loi ou de criminologie

Source : FBI, experts en criminalite

Strength : fort

Le restaurant Comet Ping Pong n'a pas de sous-sol

Source : Plans du batiment, inspection de Welch lui-meme, reportages

Strength : fort

Le FBI, la police de DC et de multiples enquetes journalistiques n'ont trouve aucune preuve

Source : FBI, Metropolitan Police, New York Times, Washington Post, Snopes, PolitiFact

Strength : fort

Les 'preuves' Instagram sont des photos ordinaires d'un restaurant familial avec salle de jeux pour enfants

Source : Analyse contextuelle

Strength : fort

Edgar Maddison Welch lui-meme, apres avoir fouille le restaurant, n'a rien trouve et a declare 'the intel on this wasn't 100 percent'

Source : Declarations de Welch apres son arrestation, New York Times

Strength : fort

Alex Jones s'est retracte et excuse pour sa promotion de la theorie (sous pression juridique)

Source : Declaration d'Alex Jones, mars 2017

Strength : moyen

Timeline

Octobre 2016

WikiLeaks publie les emails Podesta. Des utilisateurs de 4chan commencent a y chercher des 'codes'

Novembre 2016

La theorie explose sur Reddit (r/pizzagate, r/The_Donald), Twitter et YouTube

22 novembre 2016

Reddit bannit le subreddit r/pizzagate pour violation des regles sur les informations personnelles

4 decembre 2016

Edgar Maddison Welch entre arme dans Comet Ping Pong, tire des coups de feu, est arrete

Juin 2017

Welch est condamne a 4 ans de prison

Octobre 2017

QAnon emerge sur 4chan, reprenant et elargissant le recit Pizzagate

2019-2020

Pizzagate connait une resurgence sur TikTok et Instagram, souvent sans le nom 'Pizzagate' mais avec le meme recit (#SaveTheChildren)

Theory network Open in explorer →

This theory Actor Linked theory

Document corpus

Total documents 433
Co-occurrences 1
Document types
EFTA: 420 OTHER: 9 DEPOSITION: 4

Sources (5)

article Dissecting the #PizzaGate Conspiracy Theories
Amanda Robb, Rolling Stone / New York Times (2016-12-10)
nytimes.com Reliability : haute
article Pizzagate: From rumor, to hashtag, to gunfire in D.C.
Washington Post (2016-12-06)
washingtonpost.com Reliability : haute
article The Saga of 'Pizzagate': The fake story that shows how conspiracy theories spread
BBC News (2016-12-02)
bbc.com Reliability : haute
article Anatomy of a Fake News Scandal
Amanda Robb, Rolling Stone (2017-11-16)
Reliability : haute
article What Is Pizzagate? The False Conspiracy Theory That Crawled Back from the Drain
Snopes (2020-07-15)
snopes.com Reliability : haute